Table of Contents
Sliding Down the Slippery Facebook.com Slope
This morning, I nearly choked on my coffee when I read that discussed a demand from the NCAA and PSU to a student to shutdown a Facebook.com group that advocated for a prospective student athlete to attend Penn State. According to the article, the student creator of the group, John Bove, received an email from the PSU NCAA Compliance Coordinator that demanded the group be shut down immediately because it could be perceived as violating recruiting regulations.
It is beyond me how private speech by a student, who does not appear to be connected in any official way to the recruiting process, can somehow be construed to violate NCAA recruiting regulations. Effectively, this action means that universities are policing Facebook.com and other social networking sites to avoid violating athletic recruiting regulations. If universities choose to monitor social networking sites for this reason, what is to stop them from expanding the scope of this monitoring program? What is next—regulating groups which the university perceives as offensive or that hold ideas or values that run counter to university orthodoxy?
To some this may seem far-fetched, but unfortunately actions such as this are becoming more commonplace. ݮƵAPP has been forced to intervene in many cases to protect the online free speech rights of students and faculty. In one case at the University of Central Florida, a student was brought up on charges for creating a Facebook.com group which called a fellow student government candidate “a jerk and a fool.” In another incident, Johns Hopkins University severely disciplined a student who posted an offensive Halloween party invitation on a Facebook.com group.
One thing is for sure, if actions such as this continue, it will only result in more controversy. Stay tuned for further developments as ݮƵAPP looks into this apparently burgeoning trend.
Recent Articles
FIRE’s award-winning Newsdesk covers the free speech news you need to stay informed.

Judge orders release of Tufts student Rümeysa Öztürk
Tufts student Rümeysa Öztürk was jailed for an op-ed. A judge just ordered her release: If you're feeling the chill on campus, we want to hear from you. Free speech belongs to everyone.

After brazen attack on expressive rights, faculty at Sterling College aren’t in Kansas anymore
Sterling College punished two professors for speaking out — despite its promises of free expression. Now ݮƵAPP urges the college to honor its word.

Colorado reversal on misgendering ban is a crisis averted but a danger revealed
Colorado lawmakers just gutted a bill that would've punished misgendering. Call it a victory for free speech, but we should reflect on how we came so close to losing.

Zick on executive orders and official orthodoxies — First Amendment News 469
First Amendment News is a weekly blog and newsletter about free expression issues by Ronald K. L. Collins and is editorially independent from ݮƵAPP.